Help
Open Payments explained
Open Payments is the best public clue to which device companies already work with a surgeon. Read it right and you walk in knowing the likely incumbent; read it wrong and you will assume things it cannot tell you.
What Open Payments is
Open Payments is a federal transparency program run by CMS under the Physician Payments Sunshine Act. Drug and device manufacturers and group purchasing organizations report what they pay to physicians, certain other clinicians (such as physician assistants and nurse practitioners) and teaching hospitals. CMS publishes the records once a year, after the clinicians have had a window to review and dispute them.
The records come in three sets:
- General payments: consulting fees, royalties and licenses, speaking, education, travel, food and beverage, and the like. This is the set reps read most.
- Research payments: money tied to a study, often paid to an institution with the surgeon named as investigator.
- Ownership and investment interests: a clinician who holds a stake in a company.
Each record names the company, the clinician (with their NPI), the amount, the date, the nature of the payment and, often, the product it was associated with.
What it does not tell you
- Which devices a surgeon uses. A payment suggests engagement. A surgeon can consult for one company and implant another’s product, or use a device whose maker reports nothing for them.
- Anything about wrongdoing. Most payments are ordinary: training, consulting, design work, meals at an in-service.
- Contracts or purchasing. Hospital and GPO contracts, pricing and who signs off are not in it.
- This month. A calendar year is published the following summer, so the newest year is six to eighteen months old.
How to read it before a call
- Find who engages them for your procedureLook at payments from companies that make devices in your category, not every company. A spine surgeon’s meals from a drug maker tell you nothing about your bag.
- Weigh the kind of payment, not only the dollarsRoyalties are often a sign of design work and the deepest tie there is. Consulting and speaking read as a working relationship. Food and beverage alone usually means a rep has been in the room, not much more.
- Look across yearsA company whose engagement grew, or one that stopped reporting payments, can be the start of a conversation. Engagement that moved from one company to another between years is worth asking about.
- Call the result a likely incumbentThe company with the deepest relationship for your procedure is the likely incumbent, by Open Payments. Hold it as a hypothesis and let the surgeon tell you the rest.
Doing it by hand, and doing it for a territory
CMS’s own search at openpaymentsdata.cms.gov looks up one clinician at a time: search the name, open the profile, and read the general payments by company and year. That works for one surgeon; for a territory it is an afternoon per procedure.
MedaRep reads the same records for every surgeon in a territory at once and ties them to procedure families. Rank a territory and open the Competitors tab for each company’s likely-incumbent count and deepest ties, or open a surgeon’s profile for their companies by year. Engagement moved lists the surgeons whose main company changed. See Rank a territory (free to look) and the Competitors guide.
Questions
- What is CMS Open Payments?
- A federal transparency program run by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services under the Physician Payments Sunshine Act. Drug and device manufacturers and group purchasing organizations report the payments and other transfers of value they make to physicians, certain other clinicians and teaching hospitals, and CMS publishes them each year.
- Does Open Payments show which devices a surgeon uses?
- No. It shows the payments a company reported, which suggests the company and the surgeon are engaged. It does not show which devices a surgeon uses, buys or prefers, and a payment is not evidence of wrongdoing.
- How can a device rep use Open Payments?
- As a clue to the likely incumbent before a call: which companies engage a surgeon, how deep the relationship looks (consulting and royalties read deeper than meals), and whether that engagement moved from one company to another between years. Treat it as a reason to ask good questions, not as a fact to state to the surgeon.
- How current is Open Payments data?
- CMS publishes each calendar year's payments the following summer, after clinicians have a chance to review and dispute them, so the newest year is usually six to eighteen months old.
- Where can I look up a surgeon's Open Payments?
- On CMS's own search at openpaymentsdata.cms.gov, one clinician at a time. MedaRep reads the same records for a whole territory and procedure at once.
Open Payments shows the payments companies reported. It suggests engagement, not which devices a surgeon uses, and is not evidence of wrongdoing. Source: CMS Open Payments.
NextCompetitors and companiesWhich companies engage the surgeons, the company scorecard, FDA records and payment changes.