Help
Sizing a procedure market
How big is the market for your procedure in your territory, and where is it going? Public data gets you most of the way, if you know what each number leaves out.
Five steps
- Count Medicare fee-for-service casesCMS publishes, for every surgeon and every state, how many times each procedure code was billed to traditional Medicare. Group the codes that make up your procedure, count the surgeon as the operator (not the assistant), and you have a reported number. It is the only public procedure count by surgeon, and it is the floor, not the market.
- Add Medicare AdvantagePatients in Medicare Advantage are not in those claims. Divide the fee-for-service count by the share of beneficiaries not in Medicare Advantage in each county. Where 60% of Medicare patients are in MA, the claims show about 40% of the Medicare cases.
- Add commercial and other payersDivide the all-Medicare estimate by Medicare’s share of the procedure. That share differs by procedure: around half for lumbar fusion, higher where patients skew older, lower where they skew younger. This is the step with the widest range, so carry the range with the number.
- Narrow to your territorySum the counties, metros or ZIPs you actually cover. Look at how many surgeons do the procedure there, how fast the 65+ population is growing, and whether residents use more or less care than the state average.
- Look forwardA forecast built on population growth, the per-person trend and the move into Medicare Advantage tells you whether the market is growing under you. Use its range, not just the middle line.
Worked example: lumbar fusion in Florida
- Fee-for-service claims: 7,038 cases in 2019, 7,350 in 2024. On these alone the market looks flat.
- With Medicare Advantage (estimated): about 13,800 in 2019 and 18,400 in 2024. The growth was there; it moved into Medicare Advantage, where the claims cannot see it.
- All payers (estimated): around 36,000 cases a year, with Medicare about half of them.
A rep sizing this market from fee-for-service claims alone would see less than half of the Medicare cases and a flat trend. See the live figures, the metros and the forecast on the Florida lumbar fusion market page.
Where people go wrong
- Treating fee-for-service as the market. In states with high Medicare Advantage enrollment it can be well under half of Medicare alone.
- Reading a blank as zero. CMS leaves out any surgeon’s code with fewer than 11 Medicare patients, so low-volume surgeons and new ones often do not appear at all.
- Dropping the range. Medicare Advantage and all-payer figures are estimates. A number without its range invites more confidence than it deserves.
- Ignoring where cases are done. A procedure moving from hospital to surgery center changes who buys, even when the case count holds.
- Using old data as this year. CMS’s surgeon-level claims run a year or two behind; a forecast bridges the gap, with its own error.
Doing it in MedaRep
Every state and device-driven procedure has a free market page under Markets: fee-for-service cases by year, the Medicare Advantage-adjusted estimate, an all-payer estimate, the forecast to 2030 with an 80% range, where cases are done, and the metros with their surgeons and 65+ growth. For your own counties, rank a territory and read the market panel, or ask your AI assistant through the MedaRep connector: What’s the lumbar fusion market in my territory to 2030?
Questions
- How do I size a medical device market in my territory?
- Start from Medicare fee-for-service procedure counts for your procedure's codes (CMS publishes them by surgeon and by state), scale them up for patients in Medicare Advantage, then for commercial and other payers, narrow to your counties or metros, and look forward with a forecast that carries a range.
- Why do Medicare claims undercount procedure volume?
- CMS's public claims cover traditional fee-for-service Medicare only. Patients in Medicare Advantage, now about half of Medicare nationally and more in many states, and patients with commercial or other insurance are not in them. CMS also leaves out any surgeon's code with fewer than 11 Medicare patients.
- How do you estimate Medicare Advantage volume?
- Divide the fee-for-service count by the share of beneficiaries not in Medicare Advantage in that area. If 60% of a county's Medicare patients are in Medicare Advantage, fee-for-service claims show roughly 40% of its Medicare cases. This assumes MA patients have the procedure at a similar rate, so treat it as an estimate.
- How do you get from Medicare to all payers?
- Divide the all-Medicare estimate by Medicare's share of that procedure, which differs a lot by procedure: about half for lumbar fusion, more for procedures done mostly on older patients, less for ones done mostly on younger patients. The result is an estimate with a range, not a count.
- Is there a free tool for procedure market sizing?
- MedaRep's market pages are free to read: for each state and device-driven procedure they show Medicare cases by year, the Medicare Advantage-adjusted estimate, an all-payer estimate and a forecast to 2030 with an 80% range, all from public CMS and Census data.
Sources: CMS Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners; CMS Medicare Advantage enrollment; CMS PSPS; Census population estimates. Medicare Advantage and all-payer figures are MedaRep estimates.
NextOpen Payments explainedWhat CMS Open Payments shows about device companies and surgeons, what it does not, and how to read it before a call.